The products are good. My dog loves them. My local store no longer carries Side-by-Side. However, no communication with regard to the order shipping. I did send a request for an update almost a week after placing the order and didn’t receive a response. When the shipment did arrive, I found the items were very short-dated. Dec 31/23 for the food and Sept 30/23 for the treats. While the discounts were great, it would have been very helpful to know the best by dates in advance. That info could have been put on the page descriptions. There’s no way I can go through 5 bags of treats in less than a month. They’ll be getting donated to our local dog rescue.